Claire Saffitz Coffee Oreo, Ninja Creami Mode

By Jeremy Blackowiak • Created last month

Ice Cream Base
925 g
180 kcal

Description

Adapted from Claire Saffitz Coffee Oreo Ice Cream recipe for Ninja Creami.

2 cups cream
3/4 cup whole milk
5 egg yolks
3/4 cup of sugar
1 teaspoon vanilla paste (not extract! But only extract is available in the calculator)
1 big pinch kosher salt
1 tablespoon skim milk powder
75g of instant espresso or coffee, but extra concentrated, the amount of powder you’d use for for 3 drinks prepared in warm water totaling 75 g
6 ounces of Oreos (about 6). Not included in recipe to avoid impacting calculations.

6 ounces oreos, 1 teaspoon vanilla paste not accounted for in recipe. Coffee amount still TBD. In video she uses some amount of “cometeer” pods.

Instructions

Instructions here: https://youtu.be/Pz0Yx3dEFTI?si=kVzBEqL02lTYZu97

Adaptations below:

  1. Prepare instant coffee/espresso ahead of time so it can be full chilled. Prepare 3 standard drinks (as instructed on the container) worth of instant coffee/espresso powder in (75g - Xg) water, where X is the weight of the powder. Goal is 75g total of concentrated coffee. Put in fridge.
  2. Follow Claire’s instruction in preparing the mixture until after the straining step.
  3. Pour the strained mixture into creami pints. Makes about 1 quart. Freeze for 24 hours.
  4. Run in Creami ice cream mode.
  5. Chop 4 Oreos per pint into desired size chunks. Use an ice cream spade to gentle fold the pieces into the pint. Flatten the contents in the pint when done, but try not to compress the ice cream.
  6. Place back in freezer for another 2 hours.

Ingredients

g

Nutrition

Scoop (66 g)per 100 g
Calories180 kcal272 kcal
Total fat13.5 g20.5 g
Saturated fat6.9 g10.4 g
Trans fat0 g0 g
Carbohydrates13 g19.7 g
Sugars11.6 g17.6 g
Fiber0 g0 g
Protein2.2 g3.3 g
Claire Saffitz Coffee Oreo, Ninja Creami Mode

Share

Recipe details

VisibilityPublic
Likes2
Views460
AuthorJeremy Blackowiak
Created4/14/2026
Updated4/18/2026
Total weight925 g
Evaporation3%